The Decatur, Alabama community is reeling from the tragic death of 20-year-old Dontay Jamar Garner, who was fatally shot outside the 5th Avenue Food Mart on the evening of Thursday, October 30, 2025. His passing has left family, friends, and residents in profound sorrow, as they struggle to come to terms with a life taken too soon by senseless violence.
What Happened:
On Thursday evening, at approximately 6:33 p.m., Decatur police and emergency medical personnel responded to a shooting call outside the 5th Avenue Food Mart. Upon arrival, they found Dontay Garner suffering from a gunshot wound. Despite immediate lifesaving efforts, Garner was pronounced dead at the scene by the Morgan County Coroner’s Office.
Authorities quickly apprehended 21-year-old Xavier Rashawn Sutherlin, who was allegedly present at the scene following the shooting. After an initial investigation, Sutherlin was arrested and charged with murder in connection to Garner’s death. He is currently being held without bond at the Morgan County Jail while the investigation continues. Detectives are working to determine the motive and the circumstances leading to this tragic incident.
Remembering Dontay Jamar Garner:
Dontay Garner is remembered by family and friends as a kind-hearted and humble young man who had a bright future ahead of him. Those who knew him are mourning the loss of someone who had the potential to make a positive impact on the world. On social media, friends have shared memories, expressing their disbelief and sorrow over the tragic event. His death is described as a “devastating loss” and a “reminder of how fragile life can be.”
Community Reactions:
The shooting has sent shockwaves throughout the Decatur community, with many residents voicing concerns about rising violence in the area. Local leaders and neighbors have called for stronger community programs to help young people avoid falling victim to such tragic outcomes. The overwhelming sentiment is one of unity, with many expressing support for Garner’s family during this difficult time.
“I didn’t know Dontay personally, but it’s heartbreaking to see another life taken too soon,” one local resident commented. “We need to come together as a community to prevent more young lives from being lost like this.”
Investigations and Ongoing Efforts:
In response to the tragedy, Decatur law enforcement officials have urged the public to support one another and allow the investigation to proceed. The Decatur Police Department’s Violent Crimes Unit is actively seeking any additional information regarding the shooting and has asked anyone with relevant details to come forward.
Funeral Arrangements and Legacy:
As of now, funeral arrangements for Dontay Garner have not been publicly announced, but his family is expected to release details about visitation and services in the coming days. Despite the pain of his loss, those who knew Dontay are focused on honoring his memory, remembering the joy, compassion, and laughter he brought into their lives.
Dontay’s untimely death serves as yet another painful reminder of the devastating impact of gun violence in communities across the country. As the Decatur community grieves, loved ones continue to hold onto the positive memories of a young man taken far too soon.
Closing Line:
This story may be updated with more information as the investigation continues and funeral details are released by the family.
