Aaron Spencer, 37, is making headlines after announcing his candidacy for Lonoke County Sheriff on October 10, 2025, despite facing serious charges related to a fatal shooting. Spencer, who is charged with second-degree murder, is scheduled to stand trial in January 2026. The charges stem from a tragic incident on October 8, 2024, when Spencer allegedly shot and killed 67-year-old Michael Fosler after discovering him with his 14-year-old daughter.
The Incident
The confrontation reportedly began when Spencer, a father concerned for his daughter’s safety, found Fosler in a truck with the teenager. According to Spencer’s statement to police, Fosler had kidnapped his daughter, and when Spencer ordered him out of the vehicle, Fosler allegedly lunged at him. Spencer claimed that he had “no choice” but to defend himself, leading to the fatal shooting of Fosler.
At the time of his death, Fosler was facing multiple serious charges, including internet stalking of a child, sexual assault, sexual indecency with a child, and possession of child pornography, according to reports. His criminal history made the incident even more complicated, with some, including Spencer, arguing that he was a threat to children and deserved protection.
Spencer’s Campaign
In a one-minute video posted to his campaign’s Facebook page, Spencer defended his actions, describing himself as a father who acted to protect his daughter when he believed the system had failed him. He added that through his own fight for justice, he had become acutely aware of the failures within the law enforcement and court systems.
“My campaign isn’t about me. It’s about every parent, every neighbor, every family who deserves to feel safe in their homes and in their community,” Spencer said. He expressed a desire to restore trust in law enforcement, emphasizing that neighbors should know police are on their side and families should never feel abandoned during moments of crisis.
A Controversial Campaign
Spencer’s candidacy has sparked significant controversy. While some supporters view him as a man standing up for justice, many question whether his actions were justified. His decision to run for sheriff, the very department that arrested him, has raised eyebrows. His campaign message, which highlights the importance of safety and trust in local law enforcement, has resonated with some voters, while others feel his case should not be the foundation of a sheriff’s campaign.
The situation has ignited a larger conversation about the role of law enforcement in protecting families, as well as the delicate balance between self-defense and vigilante justice.
What’s Next?
As Spencer prepares for trial in January 2026, his political future and legal case will continue to unfold. His candidacy for sheriff is one of the most high-profile aspects of this case, drawing attention not only to the tragic events surrounding Fosler’s death but also to the broader issues of law enforcement practices and community trust.
Spencer’s campaign for sheriff may be just the beginning of a larger battle for public perception, as the community of Lonoke County grapples with the implications of this case and the question of whether Spencer’s actions were that of a protective father or a man seeking justice outside the bounds of the law.
Closing Line
This story may be updated with more information as it becomes available.
