Providence, Utah — The community of Cache Valley is grappling with the devastating loss of two bright young souls, 17-year-old CJ Fiefia of Avon and 14-year-old Xylie Hutchinson of Hyrum. The two teens tragically passed away following a two-vehicle crash on Saturday night, November 22, 2025, that has left their families, friends, classmates, and the entire community in shock and sorrow.
What Happened
On the evening of November 22, five teenagers were traveling together in a Toyota Corolla on a quiet stretch of South SR-165, near 1815 South, when the vehicle lost control. The car skidded into the southbound lane, where it was struck on the passenger side by a Toyota Sienna. The impact caused the Corolla to roll over and come to a stop upside-down.
First responders, including troopers, paramedics, and local bystanders, arrived at the scene quickly. Tragically, CJ and Xylie were both trapped in the vehicle and had to be extricated by emergency crews. Despite the best efforts of rescuers, CJ Fiefia was pronounced dead at the scene. He was later transferred to the State Medical Examiner’s Office for further investigation. Xylie Hutchinson fought bravely through the night but succumbed to her injuries the following morning at a trauma center.
Who Was CJ Fiefia
CJ Fiefia, at just 17 years old, was remembered by family and friends for his kind-hearted and uplifting spirit. He was a young man who brought joy and light to every room he entered, whether on the football field, in the halls of school, or among his close-knit circle of loved ones. His warm smile, resilience, and infectious laughter left a lasting impression on all who knew him.
CJ’s passing has left a void that words cannot fill. He was a beloved friend, teammate, and son whose life was tragically cut short. His community is now holding his memory close, cherishing the moments and the love he brought into their lives.
Who Was Xylie Hutchinson
Xylie Hutchinson, only 14 years old, was a sweet and imaginative young girl known for her radiant smile and joyful spirit. Her mother, Kassaundra Hutchinson, shared that Xylie suffered severe head trauma and extensive injuries throughout her body after the crash. Despite the best efforts of medical teams, Xylie passed away the following morning, surrounded by love.
Xylie was known for her kindness, humor, and ability to light up any room she entered. Her loss is felt deeply by all who knew her, and her memory will live on in the hearts of family, friends, and her classmates.
Ongoing Investigation and Recovery Efforts
While CJ and Xylie’s lives were tragically taken, three other teenagers who were in the Toyota Corolla remain in critical condition at Salt Lake and Ogden trauma centers. Their families are anxiously waiting for updates, surrounded by the community’s love and support.
The five occupants of the Toyota Sienna, two adults and three children, suffered minor injuries. Authorities confirmed that all passengers in the Sienna were wearing seat belts or secured in car seats, and none of the individuals in the Sienna are expected to suffer long-term physical effects. The cause of the crash is still under investigation, with speed being considered as a likely factor. Authorities also reported no signs of impairment from either driver.
Community Response and Mourning
As the investigation continues, the grief over the loss of CJ and Xylie is palpable. The families and friends of the two teens are mourning not only their loss but the loss of potential, dreams, and futures that were so abruptly cut short. In the days following the crash, the communities of Avon and Hyrum have rallied together, organizing vigils, offering condolences, and providing support to those affected.
Local schools, community organizations, and friends of the families have set up support networks, ensuring that the families have the help they need during this difficult time. Memorials for CJ and Xylie are being planned, with community members sharing stories of their kindness, joy, and the bright futures they had ahead of them.
Remembering CJ and Xylie
Though their lives were tragically short, CJ and Xylie’s legacies will live on in the hearts of all who knew them. They are remembered not for how they died but for the love they gave, the joy they spread, and the friendships they formed. Their vibrant spirits will continue to inspire their families, friends, and the entire community to live with kindness, generosity, and love.
As the Cache Valley community comes together in mourning, they also come together in honoring the lives of CJ Fiefia and Xylie Hutchinson. The memories of these two young individuals will never fade, and their impact will be felt for years to come.
Funeral arrangements for both CJ and Xylie are pending, and their families are deeply appreciative of the support and love that has been shown during this incredibly difficult time.
May their memories be a blessing. May their families find strength and peace in the love and support surrounding them.
This story may be updated with more information as it becomes available.
